The impact of real estate transfers on personal income tax

It’s commonly known that real estate sales are subject to tax. Less widely known is that any property transfer can affect your income tax. To avoid unpleasant surprises months or even years after signing an agreement for conveyance, be sure to get legal advice on the consequences of the transaction.

Any change of ownership of real estate affects your personal income tax. This is clear for selling a house. The difference between what you paid for it and what you get when you sell is normally a gain that, logically, amounts to taxable income. Less obvious is that income tax is due even when there is no capital gain because the change of ownership does not occur via a sale. For example, when the property is transferred as a gift or in the dissolution of a joint ownership arrangement. Yes, that is correct! Even though if there is no capital gain in a transfer of ownership, you still have to pay income tax on it.

It is also not easy to understand why income tax is payable when you sell a house for less than market value or the difference between the purchase and sale price is exclusively owing to inflation. There are even many contradictory court decisions on these questions. Possibly, in the near future, tax rules like these that don’t make much common sense will be found to run against the Spanish Constitution or EU law. As occurred with municipal capital gains taxes. In the meantime, though, we must keep in mind that any change of ownership on our property may be subject to income tax, sometimes for a hefty sum. So we must enter any real estate transaction with our eyes wide open.

Carlos Prieto Cid – Your legal adviser in Spain

Read this article in Russian
Read this article in German
Read this article in French

Read this article in Spanish

European court rules Spain must soften penalties on Spanish residents who fail to declare assets held abroad

In a recent decision, the Court of Justice of the European Union ruled that the fines imposed on Spanish residents for not declaring assets held abroad were “disproportionate”. As a result, last February, the Spanish parliament approved new, less discriminatory penalties.

Last year on this blog, we wrote about the obligation of Spanish tax residents to declare in Spain the assets they held abroad when the total value of these assets exceeded €50,000. This declaration had to be updated for changes in value of over €20,000.

Not filing this declaration meant facing fines of up to 150% of the undeclared assets, really amounting to a confiscation. And if you filed the declaration but made a mistake on it, you could be fined up to €5,000 for every error or omitted detail.

This regulation was imposed at a time of deep financial crisis when the government feared the freezing of bank accounts and offshore tax evasion. But these penalties have not held up to EU scrutiny for being clearly discriminatory against overseas investors. The new regulation adopted owing to the decision of the Luxembourg court brings the penalties in line with general tax regulations, without any discrimination for these assets being held abroad.

The time limits for these offences have also been brought into line with general tax regulations. Previously, there was no time limit on facing prosecution for offshore tax evasion.

Carlos Prieto Cid – Your legal adviser in Spain

Read this article in Russian
Read this article in German
Read this article in French

Read this article in Spanish